ok so here is the thing - this is what i said! for a long long time! like, i live in a town where our local newsletter is inundated by HAPPY HOLIDAYS! NO! MERRY CHRISTMAS! NO! letters to the editor on an annual basis, and i always thought it was the stupidest thing, the actual stupidest thing, like why are we arguing about this, it’s just a greeting, it’s just a pleasantry, it’s no big deal!!! like, i saw people getting pissed off in the newspaper and i was like, ha, i am too cool to care about this, WHATEVER, i am jewish and when you wish me a merry christmas, I WILL HAVE A MERRY CHRISTMAS! AT THE MOVIE THEATER AND THE CHINESE RESTAURANT! HO HO HO TO ME!
but now i feel differently! and here is the thing:
jews don’t typically go around saying “happy chanukah” to people they don’t know.
african americans (or rather, those african americans who celebrate kwanzaa; not all do) don’t typically go around saying “joyous kwanzaa” to people they don’t know.
but (some? many? certainly not all, but a large number of) christians do - not out of any sort of ill will, of course! - go around saying “merry christmas” to people they don’t know.
and that is because jews and african americans have something in common, and something that differentiates them from christians - which is that they are minority groups. and when you’re part of a minority group you are made fundamentally aware, from the get go, that just because something is true of you doesn’t make it true of others. it’s not a lesson you have to take the time to learn, it’s something that is made abundantly clear to you from pretty much the beginning. so for me, going around wishing people whose religions i don’t know a happy chanukah would be like going around saying happy birthday to other people ON MY BIRTHDAY. like, that is how bizarrely self-centered it would feel, to me, to assume that my holiday is necessarily other people’s holiday.
and if you’re a person who celebrates christmas, then you probably don’t have that awareness! which doesn’t make you a bad person, it’s not your fault. that lesson wasn’t forced on you the way it was forced on us. that lesson maybe wasn’t even offered to you. it’s like you’re a kid in a class where 29 out of 30 kids do share your birthday! so it’s totally understandable that you think that everyone does - or i guess, more accurately, you may know that not everyone shares your birthday, but it’s not really something that occurs to you unless you take the time to think about it. but the thing is, you should take the time to think about it. we don’t all share your birthday, and once that’s been pointed out to you, you should try to remember it.
which is why, like, when someone says merry christmas to me, i don’t think they are EVIL. i don’t think they’re deliberately being unkind or rude or disrespectful. they’re just still in that metaphorical classroom where almost everyone shares a birthday. it’s a little… i don’t know, tiring? to be wished a merry christmas over and over and over without any consideration of the fact that it might not apply to me, but i don’t get truly offended, honestly. but you know what, i get PISSED. THE FUCK. OFF by the letters to the editor i see in the newspaper where they’re like YOU KNOW WHAT, PEOPLE TELL ME TO SAY HAPPY HOLIDAYS, BUT I WILL NOT, BECAUSE: CHRISTMAS!!!! IS MY HOLIDAY AND MY RIGHT, THIS IS AMERICA GOD DAMMIT AND ALSO FREE SPEECH. because once the we-don’t-all-share-a-birthday thing is pointed out to you, you should fucking know better, and you should grow up, and you should use inclusive language. it’s not even hard.
TLDR: THE BIG DEAL IS RESPECT
happy holidays, all!